Find solutions to your problems with the expert advice available on IDNLearn.com. Discover detailed and accurate answers to your questions from our knowledgeable and dedicated community members.

Arnie was asked to solve the following problem:

A layer of crushed rock must be spread over a circular area 25 feet in diameter. How deep a layer will be obtained using 100 cubic feet of rock?

He showed the following work:

[tex]\[V=\pi r^2 h \quad \text{Formula for the volume of a cylinder.}\][/tex]

[tex]\[100=\pi(25)^2 h \quad \text{Plug in number values.}\][/tex]

[tex]\[h=\frac{100}{\pi \cdot 625} \quad \text{Solve for } h \text{ and simplify}\][/tex]

[tex]\[h=0.051 \text{ inches}\][/tex]

1. Explain to Arnie why this is wrong. (Hint: there are 2 errors in the work.)
2. Demonstrate and explain how to find the correct answer. Include proper units in your final answer.


Sagot :

Let's go through Arnie's work step-by-step and identify the errors:

1. Formula for Volume:
[tex]\[ V = \pi r^2 h \][/tex]
This formula is correct for the volume of a cylinder, where [tex]\(V\)[/tex] is the volume, [tex]\(r\)[/tex] is the radius, and [tex]\(h\)[/tex] is the height (or depth in this context).

2. Plug in the Values:
[tex]\[ 100 = \pi (25)^2 h \][/tex]
Here, Arnie incorrectly plugged in the diameter of the circular area instead of the radius. The diameter is given as 25 feet, so the radius [tex]\(r\)[/tex] should be:
[tex]\[ r = \frac{25}{2} = 12.5 \text{ feet} \][/tex]

3. Correct Step-by-Step Solution:

Using the correct radius, the volume formula should be:
[tex]\[ V = \pi r^2 h \][/tex]
Substituting [tex]\(V = 100 \text{ cubic feet}\)[/tex] and [tex]\(r = 12.5 \text{ feet}\)[/tex]:
[tex]\[ 100 = \pi (12.5)^2 h \][/tex]

[tex]\[ 100 = \pi (156.25) h \][/tex]

4. Solve for [tex]\(h\)[/tex]:
[tex]\[ h = \frac{100}{\pi \times 156.25} \][/tex]
Simplifying further:
[tex]\[ h = \frac{100}{490.8738521234052} \][/tex]
[tex]\[ h \approx 0.20371832715762603 \text{ feet} \][/tex]

So, the correct depth of the layer using 100 cubic feet of rock is approximately 0.2037 feet, which can also be converted to inches (since 1 foot = 12 inches):
[tex]\[ h \approx 0.2037 \times 12 \approx 2.44 \text{ inches} \][/tex]

Conclusion:
Arnie's errors were:
1. Using the diameter instead of the radius in his calculation.
2. Miscalculation of the height [tex]\(h\)[/tex], both deriving the formula incorrectly and the numerical computation itself.

The correct depth of the layer of rock is approximately [tex]\( 0.2037 \)[/tex] feet, or about [tex]\( 2.44 \text{ inches} \)[/tex].